Resolving the Msyteries of the Halstead Measures
Horst Zuse
Introduction
The measures of the late Maurice Halstead were introduced in 1977. These measures are widely
used in software measurement tools and by many authors.
For example, Oman et al, used these measures for the prediction of maintenance effort. Oman et al.
reported about very strong correlations between the Measure Effort of Halstead and maintenance
variables.
However, they did not explain why. Maurice Halstead died in 1979 and for this reason he was not
able to defend his measures against the upcoming criticism.
The general problem with measurement values is the qualitative interpretation of the numbers.
This is not only a problem of the scales (scales and scale types are different things), the major point
is the type of the measurement structure behind the measures and its numbers.
Halstead considers, among others, the software quality attributes length,
volume, difficulty and effort.
In physics, these quality attributes are clear defined. Length can be measured in cm and volume also
is well defined. In daily life the term difficulty in any kind is connected with time and the term
effort is expressed by imaginations of time.
In measurement theory the extensive structure is one of the most important measurement structures.
The qualitative attributes length, volume, time, money can be expressed by extensive structures.
Qualitative attributes in general, but especially for software quality measurement, can be expressed
by extensive structures, too. The concept of the extensive structure is a very powerful concept,
because it clearly separates numerical from qualitative properties.
Another thing is very important to mention: The basic idea of measurement is the comparison of
objects and numbers. Comparison is the important term! In measurement theory the definition of a
measure does not consider units. The discussion of units is an important task, however, before we
can do that the measurement structures and scales have to be determined.
The paper is structured as follows: In Chapter 2 the Halstead measures are introduced, in Chapter 3
measurement theory is explained, in Chapter 4 the Halstead measures are investigated and
discussed, in Chapter 5 we give a summary of our results, Chapter 6 contains the conclusions and
Chapter 7 presents the used literature.
http://www.informatik.uni-trier.de/~ley/db/indices/a-tree/h/Halstead:Maurice_H=.html
http://www.program-transformation.org/Transform/FatherOfDecompilation
http://www.verifysoft.com/de_halstead_metrics.html
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halstead-Metrik
Resolving the Msyteries of the Halstead Measures Horst Zuse
- Details
- Written by Jörg Ekkehard Brock